Nicalis has removed AI-generated music from Repentance Plus, the latest expansion for The Binding of Isaac, after a fan discovered the songs were made with artificial intelligence. The studio pulled the files within hours of the discovery, but the backlash has not faded.
Did Repentance Plus use AI-generated music?
How was the AI music in Repentance Plus discovered?
The problem surfaced when Reddit user ShweetsStuff looked closely at the songs used in a Grand Theft Auto-themed section of the game. They found several audio files carrying Suno metadata, which pointed back to the matching tracks on Suno's website. Suno is an AI music generator.
Did Edmund McMillen respond to the AI music controversy?
Creator Edmund McMillen responded on X with an apology. He said he “had no idea” the in-game GTA parody used generative AI music. The response did little to quiet criticism, in part because of McMillen's own public stance on the technology. In a 2024 TikTok, he called AI in game development “uninspired and bland.”
The disclosure question added to the controversy. Valve requires developers to disclose how and when they use generative AI in the development process. Nicalis, Inc., the studio behind Repentance Plus, does not appear to have mentioned the AI-generated music anywhere in its disclosures.
Nicalis moved quickly once the issue was raised publicly. The studio said on X that Repentance Plus had been updated and the generated music files had been removed. Some users on X appeared willing to give McMillen the benefit of the doubt, though the response on Steam has been less forgiving. The game's reviews have not recovered and still carry an “overwhelmingly negative” rating.
The episode highlights how difficult it can be for players and developers to track where game audio comes from, especially in a section that was meant to be a parody. It also shows how quickly a discovery made by one fan can reach a studio's storefront page and reputation.
Dieser Artikel wurde mit Unterstützung von KI verfasst.
News Factory APP - agentische News für besseres SEO & AEO.