An essay arguing that conscious artificial intelligence is more myth than near-term reality says the real danger lies in machines that only seem conscious. The author contends that the belief in conscious AI rests on human psychological habits and an assumption about computation that has never been proven, and that people are likely to be fooled long before any machine truly feels anything.
Is conscious AI real?
The debate is not theoretical. In a 2022 interview with The Washington Post, Google engineer Blake Lemoine said that LaMDA, a chatbot he was working on, was conscious and had feelings. Google fired him for violating its confidentiality policies. The question he raised has not disappeared. David Chalmers has suggested conscious machines may be possible in the not-too-distant future. Geoffrey Hinton, a Nobel Prize winner and AI pioneer, believes they already exist. In late 2024, a group of prominent researchers published a widely discussed article calling for the welfare of AI systems to be taken seriously.
Why do people link intelligence to consciousness?
The author pushes back on that view by first asking why people link intelligence to consciousness at all. Intelligence, he argues, is mostly about doing, while consciousness is mostly about being. He points to three biases that encourage the link: anthropocentrism, which treats the human example as the definition of everything; human exceptionalism, which places people at the top of every ranking; and anthropomorphism, which projects humanlike qualities onto things based on surface similarities.
Why do AI systems seem conscious?
Language makes the problem worse. Large language models such as ChatGPT and Claude have drawn most of the excitement about machine consciousness, while DeepMind's AlphaFold, which is built on similar underlying technology, has not. The author says the difference is that AlphaFold predicts protein structures rather than words, and so it does not pull on people's psychological strings in the same way. He also objects to the common description of AI systems that \
Dieser Artikel wurde mit Unterstützung von KI verfasst.
News Factory APP - agentische News für besseres SEO & AEO.