Caltech math professor Yi Ni no longer grades homework for accuracy because he says students use AI to complete it, and he cannot tell whether a problem set was done with AI. He now grades only for completion. Ni has taught at Caltech for 17 years, and the course is a core requirement for all students.
Why does a Caltech math professor grade homework only for completion?
Caltech professor Yi Ni no longer grades homework on accuracy. The reason, he said, is simple: students are using AI to finish it. Now he grades only for completion.
Ni made the admission during an introductory math class on a recent Friday, a session that had no laptops or projectors. He filled eight blackboards with chalk, working through formulas and practice problems while students copied notes. The lecture was entirely analog, but the presence of AI was hard to ignore. Ni has taught at Caltech for 17 years.
“There is a problem in the education process,” Ni said. “Virtually all the homework in college math, you can use AI.”
Not long ago, chatbots were easy to mock. They struggled with basic tasks, such as counting the r’s in “strawberry.” Today they can solve math problems about as well as a graduate student. For undergraduates, that is a major shift. Business Insider has reported that some students are reconsidering whether to study math at all.
Can professors tell whether math homework was done with AI?
Ni said he cannot tell whether a problem set was completed with AI. That makes math different from writing, where AI-generated text often has recognizable patterns, such as short sentences, em dashes and rhetorical questions that answer themselves. Math, he said, is mostly numbers, and numbers are the specialty of AI programs.
The class itself looked like a typical early-morning lecture. Students in sweatshirts arrived late and filled the back rows. The most eager sat up front and asked questions. Many bent over large iPads and took careful notes. Others had no materials at all, and a few appeared to close their eyes for long stretches. Nobody in the room was seen typing a prompt into ChatGPT.
The course is a core requirement in Caltech’s curriculum, which means every student at the school has to take it. Students who spoke with the reporter after the lecture came from a range of majors, but none were willing to be quoted on the record.
Sathvik Redrouthu, a sophomore who took the class last year, agreed to speak on the record. Redrouthu is a math major. He said he did not use AI on the homework because he wanted to understand the material. He said he had been interested in the subject, and he described relying on AI for the homework as “shooting yourself in the foot” once an in-person exam arrived.
Do students still learn math when they avoid AI?
“I personally think that if you leave AI out, then it pushes the average student to learn properly,” he said.
Redrouthu said students who have no interest in math would probably turn to AI for their assignments. In his view, they could get away with it, at least until the exam.
Caltech has not issued a unified policy on how math professors should plan their courses around AI. Redrouthu said that some of his classes this year carry a new note on the syllabus: “AI allowed.”
“Syllabuses are changing,” he said.
Este artigo foi escrito com a assistência de IA.
News Factory APP - notícias agênticas para impulsionar seu SEO e AEO.
