Alpha School, the network of AI-driven private schools that charges parents up to $75,000 a year, has won backers from Silicon Valley to the Trump administration. Its own data suggest most of its students are not reaching the central promise of the model.
Only 42% of Alpha students met the network's goal of learning twice as fast in both math and reading, according to internal data first reported by The New York Times. The findings arrive as Alpha pushes into public schools, where districts are adopting its software in hopes of packing more learning into a shorter school day.
Alpha employs no traditional teachers. Instead, it uses what it calls "guides," whose job, according to the company's marketing materials, is to "make every student feel valued and motivated." Guides do not plan lessons or grade homework, Fortune reported in September.
The pitch rests on TimeBack, an app Alpha markets as an AI tutor. The company says students will "learn twice as much as their peers in two hours of academics a day." Cofounder MacKenzie Price says the app personalizes and speeds up learning for each child, which frees the rest of the day for workshops on skills such as public speaking and relationship building.
The network has grown quickly. A spokesperson told Fortune in September that Alpha had more than 1,200 students. The Times put the figure at about 1,500 across roughly 50 campuses, in line with expansion plans Alpha announced in August.
The model has attracted enthusiasts. In September 2025, U.S. Education Secretary Linda McMahon toured Alpha's Austin campus and called its model "the most exciting thing I've seen in education in a long time." LinkedIn cofounder Reid Hoffman and hedge fund manager Bill Ackman have both publicly backed Price and Alpha on X. Sarah Cone, a venture capitalist whose 8-year-old daughter attends the New York campus, told Fortune in September that using AI well is a skill students will need.
The Times' review of the network's data shows the largest gap in math. About half of K-8 students at Alpha's private campuses missed the goal of learning math twice as fast. Roughly one in five missed their reading targets.
Students who started behind did worse. About a fifth of Alpha's private school students scored at or below the 50th percentile nationally in math last fall, the Times found, and only 37% of that group met the 2x growth goal by winter.
The two-hour premise is also under scrutiny. Guides and parents told Wired that students worked late into the night to meet the school's goals. One parent of a 13-year-old reading at an 11th-grade level said reaching those goals came with "stress and anxiety." Former employees told 404 Media that Alpha's AI generated faulty lesson plans, which internal documents said sometimes did "more harm than good." Those former employees also said the company scraped other online courses without permission.
The public school test is harder. More than 2,600 public school students in Texas and South Carolina now use Alpha's platform, according to company documents reviewed by the Times. Public schools cannot remove struggling students, the Times noted, and they lack the prize incentives Alpha uses at its private campuses.
The Houston Independent School District, the largest in Texas, is piloting the software at two schools. Superintendent Mike Miles told the Times that students spent more time on Alpha's apps than planned, which cut into other activities. He still wants AI in the district's toolkit, calling it an important tool for students to be "successful in a different world and workplace."
Alpha's growth comes as schools struggle with falling math and reading scores. Research increasingly suggests that how students use AI matters as much as whether they use it. A study of 26,811 secondary students in central China found that homework scores rose 18% after students adopted generative AI tools, while closed-book exam scores fell 20%. The OECD's latest PISA results found that daily AI users scored lower in science than nonusers, while moderate users performed about the same.
Professors have raised similar concerns. Timothy O'Malley, a theology professor at the University of Notre Dame, told Fortune in June that students who lean on AI summaries struggle with sustained reading. "Today, if you assign that amount of reading, they often don't know what to do," he said. Jessica Hooten Wilson, a professor of great books and humanities at Pepperdine University, put it more bluntly. "It's not even an inability to critically think," she told Fortune. "It's an inability to read sentences."
This article was written with the assistance of AI.
News Factory APP - agentic news to boost your SEO & AEO.